Welcome to our Forums!

Type /register while in-game to register for a forum account.

Suggestion piglin stonks

ACwavelength

Active Member
Slicer
The upcoming nether update will add piglins, a new mob which you can trade with for stuff. You can also raid their homes. This is all nice, but loka has a custom nether, meaning you wouldn't be able to find any new structures. If loka is to have these, they would have to be custom, and with this in mind, I came up with a interesting way to add piglins to loka's nether.

Piglins would basically be a stock market. When you first encounter a piglin, you'd get a popup in chat asking you whether you want to invest in the piglins for the month, or not. To invest, you'd have to pay a set amount of gold because that's their currency.
If you did this, then at the end of the month you'd receive a ton of loot either less or more valuable than what you payed them in the first place. The loot could contain things like the stuff you find in ruined bastions.

If you decide not to invest, then what you could do is raid them. There would be another big structure in the nether which would basically be ruined bastions but custom, and would have gold and regular loot hidden. Like in the nether fort, mobs would be stronger. If you decided to invest in them for the month, and then went raiding them and killing them, you'd get a lot less less than you would have done before, and a popup would appear telling you that.

If more people decide to raid them than invest in them, the people who did invest could get less, because what they payed had been stolen. If the investors protected the bastion from raiders, they could even receive better rewards. Maybe there could be a popup in chat from the piglins asking for help to defend themselves.

This could be a way to add battles to the nether, with investors defending the piglin outposts and raiders attacking them.
But I'm not going to go into that because I doubt that's gonna be a thing.

Anyway this depends if loka even updates to 1.16 and I don't think that'll be too soon, so there's plenty of time for better ideas to be thought up.
 

Evil_X

Well-Known Member
Sentry
While the piglin structures would not be present bartering is still perfectly possible with piglins spawning around the nether this kinda stock market idea might be something more for villagers considering they are still unused on Loka. It seems very complex and a system not fit for Loka but I do like the idea of some sort of fluctuating market you invest money into with the hope of making a profit (similar to Joan and Daisy Mae's turnip market in the Animal Crossing series).
 

koi0001

Well-Known Member
Guardian
I like what you're suggesting slightly and I think with some tinkering combined with the other nether suggestion we saw this could be implemented.

The only problem I see is that this is a large suggestion which kind of isn't needed.

Also, that update switch is so far on the future it's worth saying this will almost definitely get lost if you don't bump it at the appropriate time.
 

koi0001

Well-Known Member
Guardian
But gambling is?

The only problem I see is that this is a large suggestion which kind of isn't needed.

Pls don't cherry pick the sentence.

A gambling machine is super simple to setup and doesn't risk drastically further breaking the game. The difference is that this suggestion adds an entire new dimension to the game whereas a gambling machine just allows players to idle around spawn pre-fight.
 

mindblaster007

Well-Known Member
Pls don't cherry pick the sentence.

A gambling machine is super simple to setup and doesn't risk drastically further breaking the game. The difference is that this suggestion adds an entire new dimension to the game whereas a gambling machine just allows players to idle around spawn pre-fight.
Gambling and stock markets are kinda the same deal... both involve taking risks and gaining/losing currency. So yeah, same they’re both the same deal.
 

DeceitfulPear

Well-Known Member
Slicer
Gambling and stock markets are kinda the same deal... both involve taking risks and gaining/losing currency. So yeah, same they’re both the same deal.
If you think investing in stocks is the same as gambling at a casino then please take an economics class at some point.

If you want to learn more about gambling and why you should never do it take a statistics class it’s usually the first lesson they do
 

koi0001

Well-Known Member
Guardian
Gambling and stock markets are kinda the same deal... both involve taking risks and gaining/losing currency.

Really not thinking you read the reply here my man.

My argument against it isn't the ethics or reasoning behind stock markets/gambling; my argument is the suggestion is quite a lot for the server to implement when there is already other avenues of pvp or resource Creation.

I like what you're suggesting slightly and I think with some tinkering combined with the other nether suggestion we saw this could be implemented

I feel like your only focusing on the negative here hombre. If you actually read the original reply it's pretty clear I think it's a nifty idea.
 

mindblaster007

Well-Known Member
If you think investing in stocks is the same as gambling at a casino then please take an economics class at some point.

If you want to learn more about gambling and why you should never do it take a statistics class it’s usually the first lesson they do
It appears to me as if someone here fell asleep during their economics class. It is exactly like gambling, only difference is that it’s harder to lose cash cause the government is backing it.
Fishing is gambling, technically.
No, you don’t lose anything such as currency...
 
Last edited:

Evil_X

Well-Known Member
Sentry
It appears to me as if someone here fell asleep during their economics class. It is exactly like gambling, only difference is that it’s harder to lose cash cause the government is backing it.

No, you don’t lose anything such as currency...
Time is the most valuable currency out there.

Maybe take a step back, do some research and come back with a clear argument. I'm not really sure what point you're trying to make it just kinda feels like you're adding fuel to a fire that doesn't need to burn and taking things off-topic
 
Last edited:
Back
Top