I mean I'd love to go with you guys on saying that a player should be banned and that the admins are avoiding it, but you just don't have any evidence. It just seems you were looking for an excuse to try and get back at Kaph for a clean betrayal, but in reality he wasn't seen doing anything wrong. Also keep in mind that while his actions may have been suspicous, it could all just be a matter of coincidence. Theres no real reason to ban any player in any town or alliance without evidence, I think you'd have loads more support and support from people outside your own alliance (I will include ArcherSquid and Inap as part of your alliance seeing as they spent two months fighting with you against Iblis) against Kaph, till then theres no real reason to ban him other than to have the admins flex their muscles and to try to prove that Iblis members don't get banned.