To be honest, an argument can be made for both sides. For one, it could be said that he has a “devotion” to the server which means he is probably at least a little less likely to break anymore rules. But on the other hand, it could be said that because he alted, he shows that he has no regard for the rules and if he is willing to break this one, what’s stopping him from breaking others. Personally, I think the former would only really be valid if he had done it after a long time, say a year or so of being banned.
I’m not condoning alting, just explaining how it could be perceived. I have no stance on the matter.